Institutional investors have
voiced their discontent over hedge
fund fee structures—and the hedge funds are listening.
Hedge fund managers are
adjusting their business models to offer arrangements better in line with investor
interests, according to a survey by the Alternative Investment
Management Association (AIMA).
The survey included 120
managers with assets ranging from below $100 million to more than $20 billion.
Respondents said they are taking several measures to create fee structures that better
appealed to investors.
For example, nearly all (97%)
said they used a high watermark, meaning performance fees are only paid on net
new increases in the fund’s asset value. Others (33%) offered a hurdle rate,
or a minimum performance level required before charging incentive fees.
While two-thirds of managers reported
that they did not employ hurdle rates, AIMA said its usage has increased
“significantly” over the last few years.
The survey noted another emerging trend, “clawbacks,” a practice of allowing investors to take back
incentive fees paid in profitable years if performance turns negative. Though
the trend is “not by any means widespread,” AIMA said some investors and managers are exploring it.
Other more common practices
included offering fee discounts in exchange for longer lock-up periods,
rewarding early investors in the fund with cheaper founder share classes, and
giving preferential terms to investors who make the largest allocations.
More than three-quarters (77%)
said they offered or are considering implementing a tiered management fee
structure, in which fees decrease as assets under management increase.
While more than 80% charged
investors for service-provider costs and fund expenses such as audit fees and
tax expenses, over 90% said they did not charge operating expenses such as
employee compensation and regulatory reporting costs.
“Managers want to build
sustainable businesses and investors want the right kind of performance at a
fair price,” said Jack Inglis, AIMA CEO. “These are the interests that are being
ever more closely aligned.”
Funds Ramp Up Investor Incentives with Fee Discounts & Hedge
Funds Buckling Under Fee Pressure, LP Apathy