Amidst Geopolitical Uncertainty, Institutional Investors Rein In Return Expectations

Nearly half of surveyed investors said they expect lower returns from companies in the S&P 500 Index in 2026, according to research from asset manager Commonfund.



Geopolitical uncertainty is top of mind for most institutional investors, according to a survey from asset manager Commonfund. Still, the investors surveyed reported a positive long-term outlook.

The survey was conducted in person during Commonfund’s annual forum from February 25 through February 28 and polled more than 200 institutional investors who collectively manage $238 billion in assets. It found that approximately 49% of respondents said they expect lower returns for the S&P 500 Index this year than its 10-year average annualized return of 13%.

Commonfund specializes in managing long-term portfolios for nonprofits and other institutions.

Another 35% of investors reported expecting returns to be the same as the 10-year average, with 14% saying they expect higher returns, while 2% expected negative returns. Year-to-date, the S&P 500 Index is down 2.40%. The STOXX Europe 600 is up 0.46%, and the MSCI World Index is up 0.09%.

Never miss a story — sign up for CIO newsletters to stay up-to-date on the latest institutional investment industry news.

A majority of investors surveyed cited geopolitical events as the top issue facing the economy, at 52% of respondents, followed by 16% that cited rising inflation and 10% pointing to the potential for a recession.

Investors expressed benign sentiment toward the U.S. economy, with 42% describing themselves as neutral. Approximately 35% reported a bullish view on the economy, up from 22% in last year’s survey, while 17% of respondents said they were bearish, compared with 22% who said so last year.

The outlook for private markets was largely mixed, with 34% of respondents saying they expected returns to be about the same as the last 12 to 18 months, 31% saying they expected stronger returns, and another 30% saying they expected returns to be weaker.

“While today’s environment is undeniably complex, the results reinforce that institutional investors are approaching 2026 with discipline, realism and a long-term perspective,” said Mark Anson, Commonfund’s CEO and CIO, in a statement.

Approximately 59% of survey respondents said they are modestly bullish about their ability to achieve their return targets over the next 10 years, with 17% saying they are very bullish. Another 17% reported starting to feel nervous about being able to meet their return targets, with just 1% reporting feeling very nervous.

“We are cognizant of the current geopolitical circumstances that might allow for a more cautious near-term outlook. However, long-term investors remain largely confident in their ability to achieve target returns, supported by diversified portfolios, allocations to alternative asset classes, and the identification of non-correlated alpha streams,” Anson said. “We expect private equity and public equities to continue playing a meaningful role in helping institutions pursue their long-term objectives in the years ahead.”

More on this topic:

Geopolitical Volatility Defines Markets to Start 2026
Iran Conflict Expected to Fuel Inflation, Further Destabilize Market
Institutional Investors Pull Back From US Equities, See Complacent Markets Amidst Tariff Policy Shifts

Tags:

«