Law Enforcement
Supreme Court Asked to Weigh Reach of Securities Laws in Case with Potential Implications for Alternative Assets
The case could have implications for digital assets, tokenization, fractional ownership and alternative investments beyond the life-settlement market.
Reported by Matt Toledo

A petition for Supreme Court review of a case arising from the life-settlement market could have implications far beyond insurance-linked investments, potentially shaping how regulators treat tokenized assets, fractional ownership structures and other emerging alternative investments.
A recent petition, in the case Barry vs. the Securities and Exchange Commission, asks the court to take the case and clarify whether investors must rely on ongoing managerial efforts for an asset to qualify as a security, or whether a sponsor’s pre-sale work can be enough.
The petition, filed by the Investor Choice Advocates Network and attorneys from Paul Hastings LLP, seeks review of a recent ruling by the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, involving fractional interests in life insurance policies sold by Pacific West Capital Group. While the case arose from the life-settlement market, legal observers say that a potential decision from the Supreme Court could carry broader implications for investments including tokenized investments, collectibles and other alternative investment products.
At the center of the dispute is the Supreme Court’s 1946 decision in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., which established the test for determining whether a transaction constitutes an “investment contract” and therefore a security subject to the SEC’s review. Under the Howey test, investors must have an expectation of profits derived from the efforts of others.
The petition argues that federal courts remain divided over what kinds of “efforts of others” satisfy the Howey standard.
In SEC v. Life Partners, a 1996 decision from the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, held that work completed before an investment is sold generally cannot, by itself, transform an asset into a security because the value of those efforts is already reflected in the purchase price. By contrast, the 5th, 9th and 11th Circuits have taken a broader view, allowing courts to consider significant pre-sale managerial efforts when determining whether a transaction qualifies as an investment contract.
The split became more pronounced when the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed an SEC enforcement action involving three former PWCG sales agents: Brenda Barry, Eric Cannon and Caleb Moody. The SEC alleged the agents sold unregistered securities and acted as unregistered brokers, though they were not accused of fraud. The 9th Circuit concluded that investors relied on PWCG’s expertise in selecting insurance policies, pricing those policies and structuring premium-reserve arrangements, making the interests securities under federal law.
“Whether something is a security shouldn’t depend on which courthouse the SEC picks,” said Nicolas Morgan, founder and president of ICAN Law, in a statement. “Brenda, Eric and Caleb sold a product they didn’t design, under a rule the D.C. Circuit has rejected for 30 years, and they’ve spent 11 years defending themselves. Buying a finished product is not the same as investing in someone else’s ongoing work. Everyone who builds, sells or buys these assets deserves one answer, and only the Supreme Court can give it.”
According to the petition, that reasoning conflicts directly with the D.C. Circuit’s longstanding approach and creates the possibility that identical products could be treated as securities in some jurisdictions but not others. The filing notes that because parties can seek review of SEC actions in Washington, the same transaction may produce different outcomes, depending on where an enforcement action is brought.
“The PWCG petition presents a critical decision point in the interpretation of investment contracts under Howey. If the Supreme Court grants cert, its decision will be important for two reasons. First, whichever way the court decides, the decision will provide clarity and certainty among investors and promoters who buy and sell investment-type contracts,” says Paul Kisslinger, a partner and financial regulatory enforcement and litigation co-chair of Barnes & Thornburg.
While the dispute originated in the life-settlement industry, securities lawyers say the broader question is increasingly relevant as financial products become more complex and ownership interests become easier to divide, package and trade.
“In the new frontier of digital assets and tokenization, it is critical for all parties to know whether the contracts they are negotiating and signing are securities subject to registration and the other panoply of SEC and FINRA [regulations],” Kisslinger says.
The petition argues that many assets are built, selected or curated before they are offered to investors and then largely held afterwards. According to the filing, the 9th Circuit’s interpretation could allow pre-sale efforts to satisfy the Howey test, even when no meaningful managerial work is promised after the sale. The D.C. Circuit’s approach would focus on whether investors continue to rely on someone else’s work after making an investment.
“Resolving these issues will give nationwide guidance as to whether an individual is purchasing a defined contractual right, not a security, or actually investing in an ongoing enterprise, which would likely be a security if the other Howey elements are met,” Kisslinger says.
